Jerusalem Patriarchate’s Crisis
Keghart.org report, 6 November 2024
Challenges of the Jerusalem Armenian Quarter. Click here for the video (Armenian).
The following article is based on information provided by St. James Brotherhood members of Jerusalem’s Armenian Patriarchate. It sheds light on the crisis facing the Patriarchate, where transparency and leadership are in jeopardy. This is the first of several articles that will address the challenges the Patriarchate faces and what the future may hold.–Editor.
On October 26, 2023, the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem issued a cancellation letter to developer Xana Gardens, ending the controversial 98-year lease of 11,500 square meters of land within the Armenian Quarter. The action followed a series of events, including opposition by 17 members of the Brotherhood who, in 2021, signed a declaration rejecting the lease on the grounds that it violated the Patriarchate’s constitution. The decision also followed numerous weekly protests organized by the Armenian community, alongside the freezing of the Patriarch’s recognition— a decision that remains in place by Jordan and Palestine in May 2023.
However, sending the cancellation letter does not mean cancelation of the deal: there are two parties to this contract: the Patriarchate and Xana Gardens: both parties should agree on the cancellation. While only the Patriarchate decided to cancel the deal Xana Gardens didn’t agree with the cancellation letter and decided to use force and intimidation against the community and clergy. A few months later, the Patriarchate initiated legal proceedings against Xana Gardens, though the details of the lawsuit were not shared with the Brotherhood or the Synod. According to insiders, this legal action is followed by mediation attempts between the Patriarchate and Xana Gardens, which reportedly sought to take over the land unlawfully. Sources within the Patriarchate suggest these mediation efforts are stalled, with only the Patriarch Nourhan Manougian and Director of Real Estates Bishop Koryuon Baghdasaryan involved in the process, while other key members of the Brotherhood are left in the dark. When inquiries are made, Bishop Baghdasayan’s response is “Everything is going well.”
On February 18, 2024 the Armenian community initiated a lawsuit aimed at canceling the deal and safeguarding the rights of the community and the Patriarchate. The lawsuit is currently moving forward in the District Court of Jerusalem, with an expected hearing in the coming months. In contrast, the Patriarchate remains bogged down in opaque mediations further alienating the Brotherhood and the Synod from the process.
The existential threat facing the Armenian Patriarchate did not pop up overnight but has been brewing for years due to lack of leadership. Many within the Brotherhood regard Patriarch Nourhan as ineffectual while Bishop Baghdasaryan has quietly taken control of key Patriarchate functions, maintaining secrecy around critical decisions. This has led to growing calls for transparency and reform. Patriarch Nourhan, is now viewed by some clergymen as a “dead horse.” To restore faith in the institution and honor whatever legacy remains, Patriarch Nourhan should resign, paving the way for transparent and fair elections for his successor. Patriarch Nourhan should take the right decision for the sake of the future of the Holy See. It is only through transparency and accountability that the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem can function as a vital institution in the Armenian diaspora.
In 2022, Keghart published “After Me, the Deluge,” exposing the scandals and leadership failures of Patriarch Nourhan and his administration. Unfortunately, those scandals continue today. The lack of leadership threatens the future of the St. James see, a vital religious and cultural institution. In the past, the crises were attributed to Patriarch Nourhan and the controversial figure of Baret Yeretzian. Now, it is Patriarch Nourhan and those who operate in secrecy, placing the future of the Patriarchate in jeopardy.
The time has come for the election of a new Patriarch, one with vision, leadership, and love for the Armenian people and the St. James see. In these dark times, the Brotherhood and the community need a leader who will guide the Patriarchate and community with wisdom, vigor, and integrity, restoring the trust that has been lost.
The members of the St. James Brotherhood, serving both in Jerusalem and abroad, must now demand a call for general assembly, asking for answers and accountability from those who have kept them in the dark for the past years. Only through transparency and reform can the Patriarchate hope to secure its future.
Keghart will continue to report on further developments and additional information provided by sources within the Brotherhood and the various departments of the Patriarchate in upcoming issues.
*****
*****