David Davidian, Yerevan, 20 November 2024
It is a challenge for any ruling elite to maintain power. Some regimes attempt to manipulate democratic systems, which in the modern era bear little resemblance to the ideals envisioned by the ancient Greeks. The ruling gambit spans a spectrum, from classic repression to outright psychological manipulation. Entire families have remained in power for decades, including the Alievs of Azerbaijan. Haidar Aliev, the KGB chief in Baku in the 1960s, was succeeded by his son Ilham, who has been the country’s absolute ruler since the early 2000s and later made his wife Azerbaijan’s vice-president. Ilham Aliev was named ‘Corruption Person of the Year‘ for siphoning billions of dollars in hydrocarbon revenue for his family and close associates. Such a situation cannot persist without strict societal control and repression. Censorship in Azerbaijan is absolute, except when it comes to lambasting anything Armenian.
Alexander Lukashenko of Belarus has been in power continuously for over three decades, with some referring to him as Europe’s last dictator. Turkmenistan resembles Azerbaijan, with its dynastic leadership beginning with Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov in 2006, followed by his son, Serdar, the current leader. Turkmenistan has been governed as a one-party state, with the president holding absolute power. The Berdimuhamedovs have cultivated a cult of personality, marked by statues, monuments, and other tributes to their leadership.
Since the breakup of the Soviet Union in 1991, Armenia has experienced a range of good and bad leaders, depending on one’s association with the country’s oligarchs. In 2018, Nikol Pashinyan rose to power on an anti-corruption platform. However, his ascent was, by his admission, primarily ushered in by Western NGOs. As Prime Minister, Pashinyan made critical decisions that weakened Armenia’s security, judicial, and military structures while attempting to distance the country from Russia. Under his watch, Armenia lost Nagorno-Karabakh to Azerbaijan, yet he was re-elected immediately after the war and has continued to engage with Western politicians and interests. Since taking power, particularly following the loss of Nagorno-Karabakh, Pashinyan has expanded the police force—according to a December 27, 2021 OSCE report—to nearly 30,000. In contrast, Armenia’s current military consists of about 57,500 active members.
Since 1991, the best and brightest individuals typically considered part of Armenia’s leadership class have been marginalized and ignored and have never gained enough influence to challenge any incumbent regime. While this may benefit those seeking to remain in power, it is against the state’s interests, especially when alternative expertise is needed in the face of existential threats.
Historically, it is rare for a leader of a country that has lost a war not to resign unilaterally. It is even rarer for such a leader to maintain popular support. The situation can only worsen if the leader engages in national denigration, which can be explained by one or both of the following hypotheses: (1) actively appeasing one’s enemies or patron or (2) gross ignorance and incompetence. An act of national embarrassment occurred in the Armenian Parliament on November 14, 2024. By denigrating his people, Pashinyan not only compromises any ongoing or future negotiations but is also being observed internationally since an essential function of a prime minister is to serve as the chief diplomat, engaging with foreign leaders, governments, and international organizations to promote their country’s interests, negotiate treaties and agreements, and maintain relationships. While Pashinyan and his ruling party are useful idiots in the eyes of Armenia’s enemies, Turkey and Azerbaijan, third-party observers will be confident in concluding that Armenia has questionable leadership and the Armenian population shows little reaction. Pashinyan and his party members periodically make such statements, but Pashinyan’s latest, on November 14, is exceptionally egregious. With either hypothesis, Pashinyan’s declaration undermines Armenian self-perception. On November 14, 2024, Pashinyan made a statement in the Armenian Parliament, part of which is translated as follows:
“If we live in Dilijan [a town in Armenia] and claim that we are from Van [an Armenian majority populated city in eastern Turkey, with no Armenians today], we are losing Dilijan this way. It creates an opening for claims that we are not natives, that these are old Turkish or Azerbaijani cities. In this way, we are losing our statehood.” The text in brackets is mine.
Pashinyan made this statement without challenge or accountability and with little societal impact. There was some laughter when he had to admit he was from the town of Ijevan, Armenia. Pashinyan’s statement is not only a false dichotomy, but each of its parts is also inaccurate.
Pashinyan would have us falsely believe that the town of Dilijan could only be considered an Armenian town if its inhabitants negated any lineage from other geographic origins. Pashinyan dismisses the universal concept of citizenship. All this is absurd. Dilijan would still be considered an Armenian town, even if all residents claimed lineage from Armenian genocide survivors or paleolithic farmers.
Pashinyan is prompting us to falsely assume that Dilijan may not have been an Armenian town before the 1915 Turkish genocide of the Armenians. He then makes a flawed conclusion, claiming that, based on his argument about genocide survivor lineage—evidenced by his listing of Armenian-populated cities in eastern Turkey—Armenia might be in danger of losing its statehood.
Pashinyan’s dichotomous assumptions are false, and his conclusion is a non sequitur: that for Armenia to retain its statehood, its residents must not have, or admit to, any alternative geographic lineage, specifically west of the Armenian border.
Armenia created an environment where regime repression and censorship have been replaced by the absence of a critical leadership class and a society devoid of agency for any effective protest. Authoritarian regimes would envy what Armenia appears to have achieved. This condition has allowed all Armenian regimes since 1991 to operate with little to no accountability.
*****
David Davidian is Lecturer at the American University of Armenia. He has spent over a decade in technical intelligence analysis at major high technology firms. He resides in Yerevan, Armenia
Photo: The president’s residence, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia
8 comments
Photo: The prime minister’s residence, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia – The photo is the President’s residence in Yerevan. You should know this about the country you’re writing about.
David is the next useful […] in the hands of Russian propaganda. He is known for misrepresenting the facts. I can’t believe all these Western-bred pseudo-specialists singing Russia’s song. There are more and more of them popping up in Armenia. Money is good, I guess.
“However, his ascent was, by his admission, primarily ushered in by Western NGOs” – Pashinyan didn’t say that in the interview linked to this story. He said that many people who were in the opposition worked in the NGOs because they didn’t want to work in the corrupt government. These NGOs were partially financed by Western organizations. Who else was going to finance human-rights organizations in corrupt Armenia – oligarchs, Russia?
He references convenient sources. “Armenia’s current military consists of about 57,500 active members” But there are other sources too. Active personnel – 70,000 (65,000 army, 5,000 air forces and air defense) + 5,000 paramilitary (IISS estimate. The Military Balance 2024. International Institute for Strategic Studies. 2024. p. 178. ISBN 978-1-032-78004-7.)
Armenia consistently ranks as one of the safest countries in the world. Don’t you think that the increased police force has something to do with it?
Pashinyan says lots of stupid things about Western Armenia and our history. I don’t agree with him one bit. David does not either. That’s great. But he can do it without singing the Russian propaganda tunes.
Hi Andy,
The photo was the poster’s honest mistake and not the author’s. Thank you for pointing out. It is corrected.
Very good article. One comment though: it was Pashinyan’s party not Pashinyan himself who got reelected in 2021. When we speak about him as someone who was elected by the people we ourselves put him on the pedestal of the leader of our nation. In my opinion, they only got reelected as lesser of evil under the circumstances. They were perceived as guards of political power of Armenia until a new and capable political elite is formed.
Absolutely! I agree with everything that David has said in this article. These corrupt leaders have turned the population of Armenia into sheep. After 70 years of Soviet rule, they have destroyed people’s sole. There is no patriotism in Armenia anymore. Without patriotism, There won’t be an Armenian state!
DISTORTING HISTORY: David Davidian cites, a 2.46 minutes long clip of Nikol Pashinyan’s interview by Tatul Hakopyan to substantiate his claim that even Nikol Pashinyan, per his own admission, states that his ascent was ushered by NGOs. I heard the clip and I dispute David’s claim.
Nikol Pashinyan’s rose to the apex of the political system in Armenia, in a remarkably short period of time. It started with Nikol Pashinyan led My Step march from Gyumri on March 31, 2018 and ended 38 days later on May 8, 2018, when the National Assembly voted him as the Prime Minister.
It was not a consortium of NGOs that made his election as the PM a reality. But the followings did:
First and foremost, the citizens of Armenia, which is what Nikol Pashinyan emphasized in that clip.
Second was the resignation of the prime minister elect Serzh Sargsyan on April 23.
The third was the 7 members of the ARF fraction of the National Assembly, who broke away from the Republican Party with whom they had formed a coalition government, and voted in favor of Nikol Pashinyan, securing hm 59 votes in the 105-member national assembly where he needed 53 votes to secure majority. Had it not been for the 7 votes of the ARF faction of the NA, Nikol Pashinyan would not have secured the majority of NA and been elected as the PM at the snap parliamentary election, which, if not successful in electing a PM, would have dissolved and a new general election held.
Had it not been for any of the points I mentioned, and not NGOs, Nikol Pashinyan would not have been elected as the prime minister.
David Davidyan is right: it was Western NGOs – all as one, as if on command – who supported Pashinyan. And it was the Americans who called the current junta in Armenia a “bastion of democracy.” And today, seeing that Pashinyan’s rating was in tatters, only some pathetic 8 percent, they began to disown him. But we have a good memory and we will remind everyone who supported this [opportunist]. In particular, we remind Putin and his supporters, who, together with the Americans, brought this nonentity to power…
Իշխանության գալուց ի վեր, հատկապես Արցախի հանձնումից հետո, Փաշինյանը ոստիկանության թվաքանակը հասցրել է գրեթե 30 000-ի: Ընդհակառակը, Հայաստանի ներկայիս զինված ուժերն ունեն մոտ 57 500 ակտիվ զինծառայող։
Այսպիսի մի ասացվածք կա․ “Եթե ինչ-որ երկրում ոստիկանությունը թվաքանակով գերազանցում է բանակին, ուրեմն թշնամին ներսից է գրավել այդ երկիրը”։
There are any number of undemocratic countries whose military’s primary function is to protect unpopular governments from the justified opposition of citizens. Take a look at most Arab countries: from Morocco to Oman, the military’s primary function is to act as bodyguard to unpopular regimes. Thus, the military is pampered as it eats up a large chunk of the state’s budget. I understand Pashinyan has thrice raised the salaries of the security forces.
I found David Davidian’s article quite amusing. Most people agree that Nicol Pashinyan has many shortcomings; particularly being naive when it comes to international diplomacy. The question I ask of his critics is: where are all the highly qualified candidates who can do a better job than Pashinyan. As a nation we have a dearth of qualified, experienced and honest politicians. It takes time to develop and nurture politicians with strong diplomatic skills. Sadly, the two prime ministers preceding Pashinyan had oligarchic aspirations and nation building was not their priority. We are where we are because of years of corruption and neglect.