By Varouj Pogharian, Bogota, Colombia, 9 April 2026
Imagine the hush of dawn in a Cherokee village in 1838. The air is cold, the ground stiff with frost. Soldiers arrive with rifles slung across their backs, their boots thudding against the frozen earth. Orders are short and final. Families are given minutes to gather what they can. A mother lifts her child from a cradle. A father pockets a small pouch of seeds and slips it into his coat, hoping someday to plant them in soil he has never seen. Behind them, cabins stand with their doors open, hearths still warm from the night before. They will be abandoned to collapse.
For the Cherokee, the march westward was long and cold. People packed into crowded wagons where sickness spread quickly. Snow fell on thin blankets and ice formed on river crossings. Children died in their mothers’ arms. Elders fell behind, exhausted, and collapsed by the side of the road. Graves were dug in haste, marked with nothing or with a single stone. The caravan pressed on and families had no time for mourning. The graves would soon be lost under falling snow.
In the spring of 1915 in Asia Minor, Armenian families wake to the sound of gendarmes or chettes—convicts released to manage the convoys—at their door. They are told they are being “relocated” for their own protection. The men understand the lie but say nothing. The women clutch shawls and icons, and gather bread, water skins, and whatever else they can carry. Everyone has heard the rumors though few have any idea what awaits beyond the road stretching southward, toward the desert. The road fills with the shuffling of feet. No one speaks louder than a whisper.
Picture now the Armenian mother who collapses in the desert, her strength gone. Her child is pushed onward by guards. The wind covers her body with sand. There is no marker, no prayer, no place for the child to return to years later.
For the Armenians, the march southward was hot and merciless. Men were separated never to be seen again. The sun burned the convoys as they moved out of their ancestral highlands. Water ran out. Dust filled mouths. Guards prodded those who fell behind. Women were assaulted. Children wandered in delirium from thirst. When bodies fell, the convoy moved on, leaving them to the vultures and the wind. The desert became a vast graveyard, scattered with bones soon to be bleached white by the sun. Those who reached the makeshift camps in the Syrian Desert found no refuge, only starvation and disease.

The Cherokee Trail of Tears
Two marches, less than a century apart. Both began with the rupture of home, the severing of land from the people who lived and died on it for generations. Both justified by governments that saw human beings not as citizens or neighbors, but as obstacles. Each march followed the logic of power rather than the logic of compassion. Two images, two centuries, two nations.
Both tragedies unfolded under a fog of indifference. Silence became a habit. In Washington, the Trail of Tears was framed as the unavoidable cost of progress. American expansion demanded new land for cotton, new room for settlers, and open access to gold discovered on Cherokee territory. The suffering it unleashed was buried under the narrative of expansion, a national story that preferred triumph over sorrow. The cruelty unleashed on the Cherokees folded into the American myth of westward expansion. The dispossession of Native Americans was normalized, rationalized, and forgotten in official memory.
The Armenian relocations grew from paranoia and a rising Turkish nationalism that cast Armenians as an internal enemy. The Ottoman leadership saw disloyalty where none existed and imagined conspiracies that did not exist. Under the cover of the Great War, they sought to create a homogeneous empire. The marches were not relocations but engineered death sentences. The chosen executioner was the Syrian Desert.
Diplomats posted in Istanbul and across Asia Minor wrote reports. Missionaries sent letters describing the marches and the mass killings. Newspapers carried stories from witnesses. Still, Washington, London, and Paris responded with caution, restraint, and distance. Humanitarian concern took a back seat to geopolitical interests and oil. The U.S. valued strategic ties in the Near East more than moral clarity. Isolationism offered a convenient excuse for silence. Armenians, like Native Americans before them, were viewed as people outside the national horizon. Their suffering did not register as a call to action.
Dispossession versus extermination. The terms differed, but for those who walked, their suffering drowned out these distinctions. Both trails were lined with tears. One carved through forests and rivers, the other through stone and sand. Both destroyed the worlds that families had known for generations. Both are remembered not for where they led, but for what they destroyed—the worlds of indigenous peoples uprooted, their cultures shaken, and families that never found their way home again. And both left survivors haunted by the faces of those who vanished along the way.
The reasons behind each march differed in character but shared the same cold logic of domination. The governments in Washington and Istanbul claimed people were being moved, not erased. Yet the result—thousands dead, a nation uprooted—showed how little that distinction mattered in practice.

Credit – The Armenian Genocide Museum-Institute, Armenia
By 1915, the United States had still not confronted the pain it had inflicted on its indigenous nations. Without that reckoning, there was little capacity—or willingness—to see the Armenian catastrophe on another continent for what it was: a deliberate campaign of destruction. Washington’s failure to learn from the Trail of Tears meant that it lacked both the moral vocabulary and political will to respond to the Armenian catastrophe. Thus, when Armenians were driven into the Syrian Desert, the United States remained essentially indifferent, treating the tragedy as a distant problem rather than a moral imperative. Without confronting its own history of removal and death, Washington’s empathy for others remained—and still remains—shallow and inconsistent. In 1838, the tragedy of the Cherokee was defended as policy. In 1915, the indifference to the Armenian tragedy was justified as a matter of neutrality.
The Cherokee remember the Trail of Tears in stories whispered around kitchen tables, in songs, and in the quiet spaces of ceremony. It is a scar, but also a testament to endurance. They rebuilt in Oklahoma, though the soil of their ancestors remained elsewhere. A nation survived, but the wound remained open.
Armenians remember the death marches in the diaspora, spread across continents. April 24 is a day of mourning. Candles are lit for those who never returned. Testimonies are passed down in living rooms and churches in Beirut, Paris, Montreal, Los Angeles, and Buenos Aires. The Armenians’ homeland in Asia Minor was erased, towns were renamed, and churches were demolished or left to ruin. But memory is a form of resistance—the one realm the Ottoman and the Young Turks’ government could not confiscate or silence.
The legacies of these marches diverge. The Trail of Tears, despite its immense suffering, did not annihilate the Cherokee Nation. The Cherokees rebuilt, adapted, and survived, preserving their identity. They lost land and thousands of lives, but they were not erased. The Armenian marches, however, aimed at erasure. Most Armenians who walked into the desert never returned. Their towns and villages across Asia Minor—places with centuries of history—were emptied. Cultural life was shattered. Survivors scattered into a global diaspora that continues to carry the weight of that loss and risk of assimilation daily—the White Genocide.
Forced relocation is never about logistics. It is violence enacted on bodies, memory, and dignity. It tears people from the places that anchor their identity. Memory alone cannot undo these histories. But it can refuse silence. The Cherokee and Armenian peoples remind the world that remembrance is a vital act of resistance—an assertion that human beings are more than the policies that sought to uproot them. Their stories warn that when governments rationalize suffering, it becomes easier for governments to repeat it.
On the occasion of the 111st anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, let us remind the world that without honest reckoning with past injustices, governments are doomed to repeat patterns of silence and complicity. To ignore one tragedy is to risk indifference to the next.
2 comments
Dear Varouj,
I found your essay deeply moving. It does not equate two great historical tragedies, but it makes visible the profound moral kinship between them. The Cherokee Trail of Tears and the Armenian death marches did not take place in the same historical context. Yet in both cases, the language of the state tried to cover human catastrophe with words such as “relocation,” “progress,” “security,” or “necessity.”
For me, this is one of the strongest aspects of your essay. It does not only ask the reader, “What happened?” It also asks, “Through what words do states conceal their own violence?” To tear a people away from their land is never merely a geographical loss. It is the rupture of homes, graves, songs, prayers, names, and memories carried across generations.
At this point, I also thought of Alan Whitehorn’s writings on mechanisms of denial. In the denial of the Armenian Genocide, the presentation of deportation as a “security measure,” the claim that there was “no intent,” the framing of massacres as “civil war,” the strategy of mutual accusation that places perpetrator and victim on the same level, and the formula of “let both sides speak” that equates truth with falsehood, are all different forms of the state language you explore in your essay. First the state commits violence, then it gives that violence a more acceptable name. After that, it tries to discipline memory through that name.
This is why your comparison is so important. In the Cherokee case, forced removal was covered by the language of “progress” and “unavoidable policy.” In the Armenian case, the death marches were covered by the language of “deportation” and “security.” Different geographies, different centuries, different historical contexts; yet a similar logic of state power appears: first, a people is seen as an obstacle; then removal is presented as an administrative measure; finally, death is treated as an unfortunate consequence.
Whitehorn’s points about the delaying tactic of “more research is needed” and the use of threatening diplomacy against recognition should also be remembered here. Denial is not only a distortion of the past. It is also a way of managing the present. States sometimes use archives, law, diplomacy, and academic language to postpone truth; and by postponing it, they wound the memory of the victims a second time.
Your style is very present in this essay. You do not turn history into a dry comparison. You make two wounded memories speak to each other without erasing their differences. The connection you draw between the Cherokee people walking through cold and snow and the Armenians walking through the desert does not create a competition of suffering. On the contrary, it reveals the recurring logic of state violence.
This essay made me think again that forced removal is never simply “transfer” or “administrative policy.” It is violence against bodies, memory, dignity, and the future. The memories of the Cherokee and Armenian peoples remind us that even when states try to impose forgetting, the memory of peoples can become one of the strongest forms of resistance.
Congratulations, dear friend. This essay does not build simple similarities between sufferings; it builds a deep and conscientious bridge between memories.
Armenian Prime Minister Pashinyan has many denigrating, insulting & historically incorrect things to say about the Armenian Genocide.
But recall the Genocides committed by Turkey against Christian Syriacs & Christian Hellenics in the same period.
Let’s now hear Pashinyan denigrate, insult & say historically incorrect things about those Genocides & see how Assyrians & Hellenics react.